Clayface may be one of the best horror movies of the year. Working off a script by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, director James Watkins steers body horror into heartbreaking tragedy. The strength of this film isn’t its abundant discomforting scenes of fleshy grotesquerie; it’s a genuine tale of someone losing their humanity. There’s a nightmare here that feels all too real, served through sickening metaphorical visions, and only some minor surface flaws keep it in the low end of the top tier.
Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) is a rising star. Celebrating his latest acting achievement, he recklessly engages in a one-night stand with a mob boss’s moll. Gangsters punish the pretty performer by turning his face to ribbons with a razor. Unable to get parts due to his disfigurement, Matt seeks out a scientist named Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomie Ackie) and begs her to use him as a lab rat in an experimental procedure. Though it heals his face, intense side effects soon ensue. Yet, these unexpected outcomes present the actor with an opportunity for revenge.

Clayface does a superb job of establishing Matt Hagen’s rollercoaster ride. Viewers are presented with a relatively humble individual who recently reached the peak of his profession. One poor decision results in a calamitous outcome that turns everyone around him into sharks frenzied by blood in the water. Tom Rhy Harries (The Return) presents a mess composed of a kicked puppy and a raging bull grasping at anything that will restore normality. It’s a constant series of highs and lows that would shatter anyone’s psyche.
The movie wisely spends a reasonable chunk getting to know specific characters, while never sacrificing a brisk pace. Several plot elements arrive thanks to one or two lines. Fortunately, these have the kind of conciseness that makes matters clear. The way a performer regards a photo or remarks about the past says in seconds as much as any wordy exposition dump would. Plus, the story maintains a simplicity that is easy to follow.

Anyone tempted to doze off during narrative stretches is likely to be roused wide awake by truly ghastly events in the film. Clayface is not for the faint of heart. Well-executed scenes of varied gruesomeness abound throughout the movie. Some are bloody displays of haunting gore, while others are cringe-inducing segments of high-caliber discomfort. The body horror here is frequently par excellence when the special effects are working hard.
Clayface does suffer a tad from a decision to make some of Hagen’s facial transformations instantaneous. They often look like jump cuts instead of morphs. Still, for whatever reason this is done, most of his hideous body changes are frightening to behold. Audiences will squirm at the sight, and occasionally wince tearfully at his decline.
It’s likely those unfamiliar with the source material will get the most out of this horror story because they won’t know what to expect. Though the picture shares a certain stylistic quality with Matt Reeves’s recent The Batman, Clayface is conceptually closer to 2019’s Joker. As such, one doesn’t need to know anything about the comic book mythos or any other movies. Thanks to a superb cast following a sharp script, the story here reveals all audiences need to know.

Naomie Ackie (I Love Boosters) gives a tender performance that’s intriguing. Her portrayal of Dr. Corr presents someone never fully comfortable with her circumstances. That conflict creates a tension that leaves audiences wondering what her character will do when the time comes for her to make certain choices. And Clayface is, if nothing else, a story about selfish decisions.
No one in this movie really does anything for anyone altruistically. That noirish sense of selfishness permeates the narrative. The result is an interesting spin on a typical tale of revenge since none of the characters are free from responsibility for the hideous consequences that ensue. Rather than rob the movie of any audience empathy, it maximizes an understanding of various motivations, particularly central characters who often echo the idea of Jekyll and Hyde.

Joshua James (Andor) is a close friend until fear and ambition spur his disloyalty. Eddie Marsan (The World’s End) is a crooked attorney always smiling as he searches for a spot to knife clients in the back. What the two roles have in common is that they are performers who can express a sense of having had no choice, professing that their betrayals are the lesser of two evils. This theme comes up repeatedly as Clayface explores what it takes to turn people into monsters.
Unfortunately, that exploration is rather shallow when it comes to certain antagonists. David Dencik (No Time to Die) fits smoothly into the mold of dangerous mob boss Szabo. However, he and his henchman are rather generic. Despite being visually distinctive, the gangsters aren’t much more than plot cogs or fodder for gory revenge.

Director James Watkins does an excellent job of using cityscapes to help tell the story. The distinct neighborhoods of Gotham assist in suggesting circumstances such as when a penniless Hagen must return to the poverty-stricken place where he grew up. It’s literally a darker, dirtier location, and lighting choices often follow suit, accentuating particular moods. For instance, the movie opens brightly lit before succumbing to murky tones that give way to dingy darkness.
Along the way there are a few easter eggs, but Clayface is thankfully uninterested in shoehorning in as much fan service as possible. It’s more intent on delivering an emotionally driven body horror spectacle that’ll frequently cause the audience to recoil in discomfort. Driving that narrative is the fabulous chemistry between Tom Rhys Harries and Naomie Ackie.
Meanwhile, the film is visually satisfying throughout. Director James Watkins often creates the sense of a larger world inhabited by doomed individuals. Not to mention seeing how ugly the beautiful can be. The result is a living ship of Theseus presented with a touch of Jekyll and Hyde, where the nightmare is seeing someone willfully sail towards becoming a monster.

