In recent years, Chris Stuckmann’s Shelby Oaks and the underappreciated Strange Harvest have excelled as faux true-crime documentaries, movies that blend mockumentary filmmaking with found-footage to create unsettling stories akin to the kinds of documentaries viewers can’t seem to get enough of on Netflix. The new film Hunting Matthew Nichols similarly adopts the tone and visual language of true crime docs to tell a fictional story intended to scare and intrigue. Unfortunately, it does neither particularly well.
Hunting Matthew Nichols follows a documentarian (director Markian Tarasiuk plays a fictional version of himself) who collaborates with a woman named Tara Nichols (Miranda MacDougall) to investigate the mystery surrounding the disappearance of her brother Matthew Nichols and his friend Jordan twenty years ago. Both creating a documentary and investigating a mystery requires Tara and Markiant to sift through decades-old evidence and interview key figures in order to get to the bottom of a mystery no one seems able to solve. Did Matthew and Jordan run away? Did they fall and die in the sprawling foods surrounding Vancouver Island? Or does something more insidious underlie their disappearance?
In mirroring the structure of a compelling true-crime documentary, Hunting Matthew Nichols quickly hooks the audience in. The film wastes no time setting the stage for the mystery that is to unravel and establishing an eerie atmosphere. The latter is achieved through VHS recordings that creepily show Matthew and Jordan as they made amateur movies, in addition to a Twin Peaks-esque juxtaposition of cozy Americana and an unsettling undertone. Immediately, the film excels in introducing the central mystery and coupling it with a quietly unnerving tone.

Issues arise, however, as the film progresses beyond its compelling introduction and meanders along with few developments in its mystery. The true-crime documentaries that Hunting Matthew Nichols draws upon are characterized by twists, turns, jaw-dropping revelations, unexpected suspects, red herrings, and more. But despite having the ability to do what they please with this narrative structure, given that it is entirely fictional and not based on actual events as actual true-crime docs are, the filmmakers make bafflingly little use of the conventions at their disposal. Rather than encompassing an intricate and well-developed mystery, much of the runtime is spent tracking Markian and Tara as they conduct mundane interviews and fixate on a single unassuming clue, which just so happens to be key to deciphering the puzzle. There’s none of the intrigue, suspense, and mystery unraveling that one would expect from a faux true crime documentary.
The failure to work as a compelling mystery would be easier to stomach if Hunting Matthew Nichols operated effectively as a character drama, although there are similar missteps with the filmmakers’ attempts to foster investment in the protagonist. Despite the clear dedication Tara has in discovering what happened to her missing brother, the film struggles to have the audience feel the anguish and anxiety that our lead character experiences. MacDougall does a serviceable job playing a character determined to be reunited with her brother, but there’s such little work done to flesh out her bond with her brother and how his disappearance has affected her. In turn, an emotional distance between the protagonist and the audience emerges, making us care very little for Tara, her struggles, and her fate.
Erring in its attempts to be an intriguing mystery and stirring character drama means Hunting Matthew Nichols is left with horror as the sole genre it may prove triumphant in exploring. Compared to other horror movies, Tarasiuk’s film is an excruciatingly slow build that makes movies like Osgood Perkins’ The Blackcoat’s Daughter and Ti West’s The House of the Devil feel relentlessly paced horror movies in comparison. Almost entirely devoid of anything remotely sinister for the bulk of its runtime, the film eventually converges on a finale that, at last, gets the blood pumping and heart racing. The finale features all manner of creepy imagery and prolonged silences and, perhaps most important of all, finally raises the stakes for our characters. Unfortunately, the disconcerting conclusion is preceded by nearly 90 minutes of dull storytelling, uninteresting character, and not an ounce of creepiness. Does the terror of the ultimate finale reward the audience’s patience for putting up with all these issues? For us, not quite.

On a final note, the parallels between Hunting Matthew Nichols and The Blair Witch Project warrant acknowledgment. It is difficult to make a found-footage horror movie without drawing some comparison to the film that put this subgenre on the map, but Tarasiuk’s film leans more heavily and overtly into the 1999 classic than most found footage horror movies. The story establishes early on that the titular character and his best friend adore The Blair Witch Project, even going so far as to film a scene-by-scene remake. Beyond the characters’ fandom for the movie though, Hunting Matthew Nichols leans heavily into the narrative, tone, pacing, and aesthetic of The Blair Witch Project, to such an extent that one can’t help but constantly yearn for the raw simplicity of Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sánchez’s seminal film. In comparison, Tarasiuk’s picture lacks tension, finds ways to diminish the suspension of disbelief, and simply can’t burrow itself under your skin in a similar manner.
In misfiring with its attempts at excelling in the mystery, drama, and horror genres, Hunting Matthew Nichols may be best characterized as a well-conceived yet poorly executed love letter to The Blair Witch Project. Propelling forward from a strong start, the faux true crime documentary quickly disappoints and leaves one yearning for a far scarier and more intriguing movie.

