in , ,

MSPIFF26: Becoming Human Exists In A Beautiful Purgatory

(L-R) Piseth Chhun and Savorn Serak in Becoming Human. Image courtesy of Anti-Archive,

The Cambodian filmmaker Polen Ly’s Becoming Human joins the ranks of a small but proud subgenre of movies that portray the afterlife as a bureaucracy. In It’s A Wonderful Life’s heavenly meritocracy, the long-deceased Clarence Oddbody must perform enough good deeds as a guardian angel to earn his wings. Tim Burton’s Beetlejuice represents the great beyond as a kind of metaphysical DMV bogged down by long lines and Byzantine rules. Albert Brooks imagines a litigious hereafter in Defending Your Life, where celestial lawyers argue the existential justice of a being ascending to a higher plane. Even Pixar has gotten in on the game with the underrated pandemic release, Soul.

The particulars of these afterlives largely define these movies’ philosophies, so, notably, the system in Becoming Human is a casual, almost ad hoc bureaucracy. A few unremarkably dressed workers sit behind folding tables outdoors, visible only to the deceased. They’re unhurried, unbothered. One reads a list of names to call up the departed, who can begin the process of reincarnation by taking a drink of an elixir that makes them forget everything they ever learned before starting over.

A lonely journalist shows his phone to the guardian spirit of a movie theater in Becoming Human.
(L-R) Piseth Chhun and Savorn Serak in Becoming Human. Image courtesy of Anti-Archive,

Thida’s (Savorn Serak) time for a new chance has come. For decades, she has served as the guardian spirit of a dilapidated cinema that is now weeks away from demolition. One day, while sitting in the ruins of the broken-down movie palace, photographer and journalist Hai (Piseth Chhun) sneaks inside to take some pictures. Incredibly, he’s able to see Thida, and though the two can only talk, they develop a rapport with a tinge of impossible romance to it.

In Becoming Human, Hai understands Thida’s plight about as much as a living person can. He, too, is a caretaker of sorts, dedicated to a mountaintop pagoda soon to be destroyed by a mining company. The monks have all fled, but he keeps writing articles in a doomed bid to reverse the coarse course of progress. With the cinema slated for destruction, Thida finds herself relieved of her guardian spirit duties and able to travel wherever she wishes with Tai. Both of them are stuck in a purgatory of indecision — hers more literal than his. They are reluctant to let go of the places they’ve dedicated so much of their lives to, and are afraid of the greater unknown.

Becoming Human is a quiet, thoughtful, slightly somber movie. It’s tinged with tragedy, or rather, the legacy of it. There’s really nothing left for either Thida or Tai to do, and yet they’re hesitant to change, in part because they’ve finally met one another. But Becoming Human isn’t centered on romance; their never-to-be-resolved attraction is more representative of the lives they have left behind, which bind them.

There’s plenty of reason to fear moving on. Another guardian spirit confesses to Thida that she’s tempted to remain a ghost forever, because reincarnation is like a lottery. If you’re reborn rich, you may be happy, but more likely you will be poor and suffer. When we learn the details of Thida’s most recent life, that suffering becomes visceral rather than hypothetical. Becoming Human asks, even in the spirit realm of reincarnation, is anything inevitable?

It’s a lovely movie, beautifully photographed and taking full advantage of both the urban Cambodian street life and the stunning, verdant countryside. It’s so delicate, so humble in the face of great existential questions that you may find yourself wanting to like it even more than you actually do. That was my experience, at least initially. At times, Becoming Human tips from the meditative into the somnolent. Its quiet beatitude can be both a strength and a challenge, although days after the screening, the movie’s most striking images and richest ideas are what linger on, haunting as a friendly ghost.


The Minneapolis-St. Paul International Film Festival features over 200 films from around the world, plus an array of parties, panels, visiting filmmakers, and special guests.

Written by Bryan Miller

Bryan Miller is a Minneapolis-based writer who worked as an alt-weekly film critic for 20 years. His articles and essays have appeared in the Minnesota Star-Tribune, Bright Wall/Dark Room, City Pages, Nightlife, and Minnesota Monthly, and his short fiction has been featured in more than two dozen journals and anthologies.

Leave a Reply

Film Obsessive welcomes your comments. All submissions are moderated. Replies including personal attacks, spam, and other offensive remarks will not be published. Email addresses will not be visible on published comments.

Dad, Ella, Charlie, and their dog in the car

Omaha Is a Tender, Heartbreaking American Road Trip

Samara Weaving and Jason Segel in Jorma Taccone’s OVER YOUR DEAD BODY. Courtesy of Independent Film Company. An Independent Film Company Release. Bitter married couple in bed together pretending to be asleep, ignoring one another with headphones.

Over Your Dead Body Is Amusingly Dark