in ,

Sense and Sensibility: Finding the Middle to Two Extremes

Daisy Edger-Jones and Esmé Creed-Miles in Sense and Sensibility. Image courtesy of Focus Features.

Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility has stood the test of time. Written in 1811, the novel has endured in popularity for 215 years. It tells the story of two sisters, Elinor and Marianne, in their attempts to find suitable partners before they are left destitute. Despite being sisters, the two approach life (and love) quite differently. While Elinor values pragmatism and keeps her feelings close to her chest, her sister embodies the wild Romantic. Elinor puts societal reasoning first and foremost. Meanwhile, Marianne wants to marry purely for love. Yet both need money to survive.

This 2026 adaptation of Sense and Sensibility sticks fairly close to the novel, and in doing so succeeds as an adaptation. The casting choices are spot on, the story is moderately easy to follow, and it’s quite funny at times. It also touches on some themes which are still relevant today. Overall, if Jane Austen were still alive, she’d enjoy watching this one.

It’s the 1790s, and Elinor (Daisy Edgar-Jones) and Marianne (Esmé Creed-Miles) are in a bit of a pickle. Their stepfather, Henry Dashwood, is dead. He made his son, John, promise to provide for Elinor and Marianne through his inheritance. However, his wife, Fanny, convinces him to barely provide for them. Thus, they are left in quite a precarious situation.

Elinor (Daisy Edgar Jones) and Marianne (Esmé Creed-Miles) lie next to each other on a bed, smiling.
Esmé Creed-Miles and Daisy Edgar-Jones in Sense and Sensibility. Photo courtesy of Focus Features.

Luckily enough for Elinor, Fanny’s brother Edward Ferrars (George MacKay) arrives soon after. The two of them quickly form a strong bond. Later in the story, Marianne finds her own suitor, John Willoughby (Frank Dillane). But are these men all they seem to be? And there is another man interested in Marianne’s hand as well, Colonel Brandon (Herbert Nordrum). Nevertheless, he seems too passionless for the idealistic Marianne.

The movie navigates these relationships with twists and turns through a story that explores and critiques the need for women to rely entirely on men for social survival. Sometimes, that reliance leads to manipulation to survive. Both Elinore and Marianne must also learn to see things from the other sister’s point of view and take a more middle-ground stance on their ideals. Though there are bumps in the road, the film ends typically of a Jane Austen story.

The filmmaker and director, Georgia Oakley, did an excellent job in capturing the locales of Sussex and Devon in 18th-century England. The landscapes are beautiful, and nature is one of the film’s best features. London itself appears in the film, and it’s wonderful to behold.

It’s also wonderfully interesting to see how women and men interacted back in those times. As said before, women relied entirely on men for their safety and financial security. This not only led unethical women to sometimes rely on manipulation but also led women to be manipulated by unscrupulous men. Both of these situations are explored within the film.

Elinor (Daisy Edgar Jones) and Edward Ferrars (George MacKay) stand next to each other on a lake dock.
Daisy Edgar-Jones and George MacKay in Sense and Sensibility. Photo courtesy of Focus Features.

Furthermore, exactly how men and women passed the time back in the 18th century, whether in artistry, piano playing, or sculpting, is portrayed. Anyone with a passing interest in learning more about the past and how society lived, what they wore, and how they talked will have their curiosity satisfied.

Speaking of language, at times the film is somewhat difficult to follow. It may take a while for audience members to adjust to how these characters converse. This isn’t a flaw, per se, but it does require intense concentration for those not familiar with the vernacular.

Elinor and Marianne are both perfectly cast. Elinor has a sharp beauty to her, which suggests a much more contained and pragmatic personality, while Marianne’s physical makeup portrays a much wilder one. Daisy Edgar-Jones captures Elinor’s personality in every possible way, whereas Esmé Creed-Miles portrays a playful, sentimental Marianne. Other members of the cast also make an impact. Turlough Convery plays Sir John Middleton, who will no doubt have audiences comparing his performance to Jack Black, with both his looks and comedic energy. Herbert Nordrum also plays a very restrained and likeable Colonel Brandon. And finally, Mrs. Jennings (Fiona Shaw) will have viewers in fits of laughter.

If you are at all a Jane Austen fan, this film will capture your heart and then some. It tells one of Austen’s most well-known stories while entertaining with wit and heart. It is as well educational in the telling of it, with many themes to unpack. Edgar-Jones and Creed-Miles play their parts excellently, and the rest of the cast hits the mark too. It serves as a perfect entry point into Austen’s canon.

Written by Aaron Ploof

Aaron has been an avid fan of films since his youth. His favorite filmaker is David Lynch and he enjoys discussing his various works, especially Twin Peaks. His other admired directors are Bluth, Aronofsky, and P.T. Anderson. While he's not watching films and writing, he spends the hours playing both board and video games, as well as reading literature and acting in plays. He holds an English and Theatre Bachelor Degree from Anderson University and resides in Noblesville, Indiana.

Leave a Reply

Film Obsessive welcomes your comments. All submissions are moderated. Replies including personal attacks, spam, and other offensive remarks will not be published. Email addresses will not be visible on published comments.

a man and woman stare upwards

The Cinephile Hissy Fit Reevaluates La La Land

AFI Fest 2026: The Mara Sisters Fuse In Absurd Bucking Fastard